As Manchester United prepare for another rebuild under new leadership and possibly a new manager, one area stands out for improvement: the striker position. Despite Rasmus Højlund’s flashes of promise, inconsistency and lack of cutting edge in front of goal have left United considering reinforcements. Two names frequently linked are Ollie Watkins of Aston Villa and Benjamin Šeško of RB Leipzig.

So how do these two targets compare to Højlund? And what could each bring to Old Trafford?

Rasmus Højlund: A Work in Progress

Age: 22
Nationality: Denmark
Strengths: Physicality, work rate, off-the-ball movement
Weaknesses: Finishing consistency, link-up play, confidence under pressure

Højlund was brought in as a long-term project. He has shown potential, especially in European competitions, and his athletic profile fits the mold of a modern striker. However, over the past season, his Premier League output has been underwhelming. Long goal droughts and an overreliance on physical attributes have raised concerns about whether he can develop quickly enough to lead the line for a club of United’s stature.

Ollie Watkins: The Premier League-Proven Finisher

Age: 29
Nationality: England
Strengths: Clinical finishing, movement in the box, creativity, high pressing
Weaknesses: Age, resale value, limited top-level European experience

Watkins has steadily grown into one of the most reliable forwards in the Premier League. He offers much more than goals—his off-ball work, ability to link play, and pressing from the front make him ideal for a high-intensity system. Watkins also contributes assists, making him a dual threat. While he’s nearing 30, his maturity and proven track record in the league make him an attractive short-term solution.

Why Watkins makes sense for United:

• He could slot in immediately and deliver consistent performances.
• He would reduce the pressure on Højlund and offer competition.
• His intelligence and movement would complement wide attackers like Garnacho and Rashford.

Benjamin Šeško: The Future Star?

Age: 21
Nationality: Slovenia
Strengths: Height (6’5″), pace, clinical finishing, potential
Weaknesses: Limited top-level experience, needs tactical development

Šeško is seen as one of Europe’s most promising young strikers. With a build reminiscent of Erling Haaland and a growing reputation in the Bundesliga, he possesses raw power, aerial dominance, and goal-scoring instincts. While not yet the finished product, he’s shown signs of a player who could become world-class with the right development.

Why Šeško could be the ideal investment:

• Offers long-term upside and resale value.
• Provides a different attacking profile—taller, more physical, dominant in the air.
• Could develop alongside Højlund or eventually replace him as the leading striker.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Tactical Fit Under Amorim (or Future Manager)

Whether United stick with their current direction or bring in a coach like Rubén Amorim, the striker will need to fit a system based on pressing, fluid movement, and transitional play. Watkins is ready-made for that system, while Šeško would need adaptation time but could become a long-term weapon. Højlund, while hardworking, still struggles with decision-making and composure.

Conclusion

If United want a striker who can immediately elevate their front line, Ollie Watkins is the most Premier League-ready option. But if the club are focused on the future and want a high-upside signing who could explode in the next few years, Benjamin Šeško may be the smarter investment.